Placement readiness · Case examples

Three cases. Three families.

Run these with a partner: one plays candidate and sees only the brief; the other plays interviewer and reveals each exhibit only once the candidate's structure earns it. All three companies are fictional, written for this site.

Before you open the first exhibit

State your structure before you see a single number.

  1. What decision is actually being asked for, and by when?

  2. Which two or three branches of your structure would you check first, and why those?

01 / Market entry

QuickRide: should it launch two-wheeler taxis in Tier-2 cities?

Candidate brief · Read aloud

QuickRide is a fictional ride-hailing app operating four-wheeler cabs in six metro cities. Short, congested trips in several Tier-2 cities make a low-cost two-wheeler taxi service look attractive, and leadership is considering launching in three of five candidate cities. Should QuickRide enter, and if so, where and how?

Exhibit 1 · Candidate city dataReveal
CityPopulationAvg trip lengthLocal competitorIncome level
City A18 lakh3.2 kmWeak — one small local playerLower-middle
City B22 lakh4.1 kmNoneMiddle
City C14 lakh2.8 kmStrong — an established local appLower-middle

Candidate task: use this to judge attractiveness and accessibility across the three cities — which looks winnable, and which looks like a hard fight for second place?

Exhibit 2 · Unit economicsReveal

Average fare per trip

₹35

Platform take rate

20%

Driver net earning per trip

₹28

Trips per driver per day needed to break even on onboarding cost

≈ 12

Interviewer guide · What a strong synthesis containsReveal

City B is the strongest first move — no incumbent, the largest population and a favourable income profile — even though City A and City C have shorter trips that suit two-wheelers slightly better. Entering an uncontested city first lets QuickRide learn the operating model before it has to fight an entrenched local player in City C. A recommendation that leads with City C because it “looks most like a two-wheeler market” without weighing the competitive response is missing the accessible/winnable half of the framework.

  • Probe: what would make you enter City C anyway, and on what terms?
  • Probe: how many drivers does the break-even trip count actually require?
  • Probe: what is the biggest assumption behind the fare and take-rate numbers?

02 / Growth

PagesFirst: new physical stores, or go online-first?

Candidate brief · Read aloud

PagesFirst is a fictional 40-store regional bookstore chain with flat same-store growth. Management has ₹3 crore to invest and is deciding between opening roughly seven new physical stores or building an online/omnichannel platform. Recommend a path.

Exhibit 1 · Store vs. online economicsReveal
MetricNew physical storeOnline platform
Upfront investment₹45 lakh per store₹3 crore platform build (one-time)
Payback period≈ 30 months per store≈ 20 months, if scale is reached
Gross margin38%44% (no store rent or staff)
Customer reachLocal catchment onlyNational, but crowded and discount-driven
Exhibit 2 · How existing customers discover new titlesReveal

A recent customer survey: 58% discover new titles by browsing in-store, 27% through staff recommendations (also in-store), and only 15% through any online channel today. PagesFirst's core customer relationship is currently built almost entirely around the physical browsing experience.

Interviewer guide · What a strong synthesis containsReveal

The faster payback on the online platform is real, but Exhibit 2 shows why a pure online-first bet is risky: 85% of demand today is generated by the in-store experience the company would be de-emphasising. A stronger recommendation phases the investment — three or four new stores in proven catchments, funding a smaller online pilot alongside them, and using that pilot's actual conversion data (not the case exhibit's assumptions) before committing the full ₹3 crore either way.

  • Probe: what capability does PagesFirst lack to run online well?
  • Probe: how would you measure the pilot before scaling it?
  • Probe: does going all-in on stores also carry a real risk? Which one?

03 / Pricing

MetricLens: flat fee, or usage-based pricing?

Candidate brief · Read aloud

MetricLens is a fictional B2B analytics tool charging every customer the same flat monthly fee. Some customers use it constantly; others barely log in. Leadership is considering a usage-based, tiered model. Should they change, and how?

Exhibit 1 · Customer usage segmentsReveal
SegmentShare of customersShare of revenueWillingness to pay more
Light users55% of customers12% of revenueLow — mostly cost-sensitive
Medium users30% of customers33% of revenueModerate
Heavy users15% of customers55% of revenueHigh — usage far exceeds flat fee value
Interviewer guide · What a strong synthesis containsReveal

The heavy-user segment is only 15% of customers but 55% of revenue and clearly under-priced relative to the value they extract — that is where a usage-based tier should be introduced first. Light users are the majority of customers by count and price-sensitive; moving them to usage-based pricing risks churn for little revenue gain. The stronger recommendation keeps a flat, predictable entry tier for light and medium users, and introduces a usage-based premium tier targeted at the heavy segment, with existing heavy users grandfathered onto a transition price for a defined period to manage the change.

  • Probe: what would you measure to confirm heavy users won't simply leave?
  • Probe: how would you communicate the change to avoid feeling punitive?
  • Probe: does this pricing change affect the sales motion, not just revenue?

Continue practising

Turn structure into a habit.

Dr. Swapnil Sahoo AI Mentor

Prerecorded welcome · synthetic voice

About this video

The welcome is prerecorded, with an AI-created likeness and a stock synthetic voice. It does not answer questions. Replies below are prepared website guidance; a trained personal live replica is not connected unless explicitly offered.

Welcome transcript · Download captions

Digital guide

Hello. Watch my welcome, type a question or enable voice below. I offer prepared guidance from Dr. Swapnil Sahoo’s published materials. Learning tools help you find a path, explain a lesson or practise a decision.

Voice input and privacy

Browser voice may send audio to its speech service. Spoken replies use a standard device voice, not Dr. Sahoo’s voice. This website does not save your conversation.

Voice input is not supported here. Type your question instead.